Reviews

Well done!

I’m really impressed with this podcast. It’s a fascinating story and so well told. I would’ve given it 5 stars if not for the short episodes!

silverthad
Dec. 16, 2022

I am really picky about podcasts and don’t typically go for things with shorter episodes however I really liked this one. It was easy to listen to and I binged it while housecleaning. I really appreciate that this was a “normal” person telling us about something that interested them instead of some huge production. I wish my hobbies were this cool!

maddysen28
July 9, 2021

Keep it going!!!

I really enjoyed your podcast and truly hope you continue!!!

fritz6
June 14, 2021

Stick with it! Listen to all.

I listen to lots of True Crime podcasts. I just finished listening to this from beginning to end. So many negative comments & ratings here. Yes, he’s not an experienced podcaster. Yes, he recaps. Yes, he has short episodes. Yes, he refers to “my wife” often. I think the fact that this case has gotten new attention is wonderful! The podcast evolves over time. I love the fact that this is a husband/wife duo. I say great job! I just subscribed to Why So Cold and look forward to following you on your podcasting journey. 5⭐️ from me!

allopez1
April 1, 2021

I’ve listened since the beginning

Although it might seem slow...it’s really well put together for a first time podcast imo!

Davvi_
March 30, 2021

Good podcast but could be better

This podcast is good The gentlemen has a good voice But I feel like it can be better But don’t give up I think this podcast can be popular Good up the great work

Dsingh3
April 18, 2020

Like Re-Living The Past

I moved from Stafford to Orange County in 1997, near where this happened. I lived thru this horror. The episode mentioning Silva/Lisk murders brought me to shivers, I new the Silva family very well during that time. I hope this can be solved for everyone involved.

Trie Crime Addicted
Feb. 13, 2020

I’ve binge listened to this podcast in 2 days!

I absolutely commend you for what you are trying to do. I think you’re really on to something with that auto place and the 30 day tags. I’m glad you are feeling better and really looking forward to season 2! Great job! Let’s find this SOB!

Nik614
Nov. 12, 2019

Love this

I have listened to countless podcasts, and I got to say -I am so glad I found this one. Job well done folks.

Spankey78
June 12, 2019

Love it

Great job!! Kudos for shedding light and putting pressure on authority used to properly address crimes targeting women in a small regional. If those with criticisms around professionality think they can do better…then go for it . Hoping you will produce more!

Laurel Paliatina
May 1, 2019

Great podcast!

I live in the Fredericksburg area & had no idea about this. Love this podcast. Totally hooked!!

Jra4776
March 18, 2019

Thank you!!!!!!

Thank you sooo much for covering Alicia’s case. I think this and the other route 29 and colonial parkway Murders are solvable. It’s just a matter of getting the right break for law enforcement or having the right person who knows something come forward. Podcasts like yours that can get the information out to lots of people are critical. Thank you for taking the time and putting up with all the criticism as well. I think those who have never tried podcasting should keep their overly critical opinions to themselves. Your podcast comes across as heartfelt and sincere. That is the most important aspect of anything you do in life. Thanks again for your hard work and dedication.

bmarieMac
March 15, 2019

He’s still out there

I’ve been researching the Route 29 stalker for about a week now, so I am clearly no expert but I have noticed a few particular trends that the stalker has, and I think it could be beneficial to this podcast. This podcast is detailing events that took place from 2014 to now, and it’s terrifying to think girls are being abducted by a serial stalker/murderer. I think he is a student at one of the colleges who is holding a deep grudge against younger women.

Repulsion
Feb. 28, 2019

Awesome

I really like this podcast. I like the narrator’s voice. It’s very soothing. The podcast is very informative and contains a lot of mystery. Great job.

marky5555555
Feb. 21, 2019

Interesting!

I really enjoy this podcast. It is kinda weird they are super short, but I like it. It’s an interesting topic I was not aware of!

r_wine
Feb. 15, 2019

Excellent

Short episodes, but the production quality and investigation are top notch.

TheRealBilgeRat
Jan. 23, 2019

Decent

Decent podcast, but too much wasted time. We don’t need to hear all the ringtones, answering machine messages, missed calls and insignificant conversations. Cut out the fat, get to the point. This could definitely be a very good podcast, but needs some adjustments. In my humble opinion.

sclanton2
Jan. 19, 2019

Binged

I binged this podcast to catch up! Hope it stays edgy.

Lynds05!
Jan. 10, 2019

VA Killer

I grew up in Lynchburg, and I've been convinced that there is / was a serial killer in the area for years.Cool to see someone else taking an closer look!

Bethsward
Jan. 9, 2019

Gotta Stop The Monsters

Thanks to your wife for encouraging your doing a podcast. I’m convinced that citizens networking and sharing info can put a stop to a lot of these monsters. If law enforcement can’t arrest them maybe we can educate ourselves enough to at least slow down their carnage. Thanks again for your dedication.

IRONWINGS ART
Jan. 5, 2019

Great Listen - Too Many Ads

This is a great podcast! Easy listen but the episodes are very short and there are adds to start and end each one that take up a huge chunk in time. Glad he’s putting this story out there!

Natalie Shadid
Jan. 5, 2019

Addicting

Great podcast from a fellow Lynchburgian! Definitely would LOVE to have longer episodes. I really enjoy the episodes where Woody asks plausible questions about the case out loud or “brainstorming” out loud. Gets your wheels spinning. 😉 great job Woody!

hilbish
Jan. 5, 2019

Thank you

Thank you so much for covering this case and series of cases. I have asked other podcasters to look into this but y’all are the first I have seen to take a serious look. I have only listened to the first episode so far but I am looking forward to any new information or leads you might uncover. I think a crowd sourced revisit to the case, reaching out to possible witnesses in a way only a podcast can effectively do could break something open. Please keep it up! Alicia and the other victims and potential victims need a hero like you to bring them justice.

RFM40
Jan. 4, 2019

Intriguing but...

You spend so much time out of such short episodes on a repetitive intro. The current episode didn't start until 4 minutes into a 22 minute episode.

LamzyLyn
Jan. 3, 2019

Awesome!

Really enjoying this podcast. I’m a Nelson County native and Route 29 is the hub for transportation to Lynchburg or Charlottesville, or really anywhere for that matter. I was young when these events happened, but with the disappearances in Charlottesville and Alexis Murphy (my hometown), this podcast really hits home and can’t imagine the fear people were feeling during this time. I’ve had the pleasure of meeting Woody when we worked for the same organization and knew he was a talented guy, but man, he and his wife are doing a phenomenal job with this podcast. I really wish the episodes were longer though. Sometimes I feel as if I hear more music than the story/dialogue (don’t get me wrong, the music sets/reflects the mood for the podcast).

haasebritt
Dec. 23, 2018

Great show

I wish the episodes were a bit longer. I have shared the podcast on other podcast group forums on FB!

saraelizabethcooper
Dec. 19, 2018

Love it as well

I love the podcast just need longer episodes

CahmilleGwynXD😝
Dec. 12, 2018

Love it

I really really love this podcast but I wish the episodes were a bit longer.

thekeekee
Dec. 6, 2018

I’m HOOKED

I’m obsessed with cold cases. I absolutely loved “Up and Vanished” and “Serial” and this is my new favorite. I’ve listed to every episode (more than once) and each time I can’t wait for the next one. Great job on this podcast!

zoesaylor
Oct. 16, 2018

Great podcast

Good work, Woody! Really enjoy this podcast and the level of digging and thread/pulling Woody does to in this podcast.

timbabewe
Oct. 8, 2018